Wednesday, January 21, 2015

A “Merkel Plan” for Europe


JAN 19, 2015

By Bill Emmott


LONDON – Ever since Europe’s economic crisis erupted more than four years ago, politicians and pundits have clamored for a grand solution, often invoking the example of America’s postwar Marshall Plan, which, starting in 1948, helped to rebuild Western Europe’s shattered, debt-ridden economies. But the political moment has never been ripe. That could be about to change.
Europe’s situation today bears some similarities to the 1940s. Burdened by the public debts resulting from past mistakes, eurozone governments know what they need to do but not how to do it. They mistrust each other too much to collaborate. Meanwhile, demand in most of the European Union is weak, ruling out the economic growth needed to repay debts and offer hope to the 25 million unemployed.


Parochial suspicion has been the main obstacle to a grand solution. No country’s taxpayers have wanted to feel that they are paying for others’ excesses: the single currency did not impose shared responsibility. So creditor countries, led by Germany, have sought to do the minimum necessary to keep the euro alive, while debtors have grumbled impotently about Germany’s insistence on fiscal austerity.
The two sides disagree about the nature of the European sickness, and when there is no agreement on the diagnosis, it is hard to agree on a cure. Yet a convergence may be at hand, owing to developments in Greek, Spanish, and British politics, as well as to the simple passage of time.
Greeks look poised to elect on January 25 a government dominated by the far-left Syriza party, which once stood for repudiation of the euro but now pledges to negotiate a restructuring of Greece’s debts. Spain’s most popular party ahead of the general election due at the end of this year is Podemos, which was founded only in January 2014 and has views similar to Syriza’s. And the United Kingdom’s election in May will rock the European boat by focusing on the question of when Britain should hold a referendum on whether to leave the EU.
These political rumbles worry creditor countries, which is reflected in the frequency of warnings from Germany that any new Greek government must adhere to existing agreements. That is a sure indicator that Germany fears that Syriza will not do so. The bargaining has begun.
The passage of time ought to help with this bargaining. Germany’s formula for the euro crisis has been to insist on fiscal belt-tightening and structural reforms to reduce future public spending on pensions and wages, make labor markets more flexible, and boost productivity, all in return for emergency loans. Since the crisis began, the main recipients – Greece, Ireland, Spain, and Portugal – have been following that formula.
As a result, it is becoming possible, in political terms, to say that the debtors have taken their punishment and have made their economies more competitive. Economic growth has rebounded strongly in Ireland, mildly in Spain and Portugal, and meagerly in Greece. What is now holding back these and other European economies is weak demand in the eurozone as a whole.
That is why a modern version of the Marshall Plan is needed. Politically, it would be smart if German Chancellor Angela Merkel were to take the initiative in proposing such a grand solution, rather than being forced into piecemeal, reluctant concessions by new governments in Greece, Spain, or elsewhere.
It would be even smarter to share that initiative with the leaders of Europe’s other big economies: French President François Hollande, who, following the terrorist attacks earlier this month, is perhaps especially receptive to efforts to promote unity and economic growth, and British Prime Minister David Cameron, who would welcome signs of European reform.
A modern Marshall Plan should have three main components. First, sovereign debt in the eurozone would be restructured to ease the pain suffered by Greece and Spain. Second, a collectively financed public-investment program would focus on energy and other infrastructure. Third, a timetable for the completion of single-market liberalizing reforms – notably for service industries and the digital economy – would be established.
In Germany, debt restructuring would be the most controversial component. But Germans should be reminded that, along with Marshall Plan funds for Western Europe, the other big boost to Germany’s postwar economic recovery came from debt restructuring. The London Agreement of 1953 canceled 50% of Germany’s public debt and restructured the other half to give the country much longer to repay.
Though a write-off of eurozone debts would be politically difficult, it would be possible to refinance a large proportion with longer maturity Eurobonds, which all eurozone countries would underwrite. What is crucial is that such a remedy is extended to all eurozone members, rather than singling out one country (Greece).
By including the other components of public investment and single-market completion, the Merkel Plan (or, better, the Merkel-Hollande-Cameron Plan) would be able to restart economic growth while opening countries to more trade and greater competition. This addresses one of the principal British complaints about the EU: that it has so far failed to complete the single market, a project partly initiated by Margaret Thatcher in the 1980s.
Of course, a modern Marshall Plan would face a wall of skepticism and obstruction by national interest groups. But, by standing together, European officials could win that battle. And if it is not tried, tomorrow’s Europeans may never forgive today’s leaders.


Bill Emmott, a former editor of The Economist, is the author of Good Italy, Bad Italy, and The Rivals: How the Power Struggle Between China, India, and Japan Will Shape Our Next Decade.


Read more at http://www.project-syndicate.org/columnist/bill-emmott#EUVbp6TJd1I3PFiT.99

3 comments:

  1. Excellent blog here! Also your site loads up very fast! What web host are you using?
    Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my site loaded
    up as fast as yours lol

    my web blog :: homes ideas [www.homeimprovementdaily.com]

    ReplyDelete
  2. Welcome to Lowry Electrical, Plumbing, Heating & Cooling!
    If you have arrive here looking for the best electrical heating and cooling contractor, then look
    no further - you discovered us. We know the electrical and HVAC business within and out.
    After all, we have been in the company for 3 decades.

    You can usually rely on Lowry Electric, Heating & Cooling
    specialists to provide high quality customer services because we believe you shouldn't anticipate anything less.
    It is our mission to provide the best services available and to get the occupation done right the first time and each time.


    Attach them to presents or use them as nametags.
    How about location markers at the supper table? For Christmas,
    rather of placing nametags on the presents, use toys in a
    theme and then on Xmas early morning, let each kid know which theme
    is theirs. They will have just as much fun figuring
    out whose package deal is who's as they will discovering out what is
    within the package deal.

    REMEMBER: A individual's free name tag templates for mac is the sweetest
    audio they will hear in any language. When you
    use their names, you will make them feel appreciated, welcome and essential.
    Perhaps it's printed on a plastic clip. Perhaps it's written on a paper nametag.

    Even if it hangs from a lanyard, stares you in the face, appear at it, and SAY IT!
    Step onto their entrance porch, and WOW them!

    I've always held the belief that everyone can educate you something.
    That everyone has a tale to tell. And that everybody can impact you in some way.

    So, by much the greatest advantage to wearing a nametag all the time was the chance to satisfy new
    individuals. Individuals I wouldn't have met or else. People that,
    often times, became friends of mine! It almost grew to become addicting!



    The Airport Safety put a lady on our case. I went to the
    Rest Room while the intercom was saying 'All unattended baggage will be turned
    more than to the Chicago Law enforcement Dept.' I thought we'd by no means
    see that case again. Nevertheless, inside about forty minutes, the lady arrived with our bag!
    We had been so overjoyed we both gave her a large hug and thanked her.
    We had been happy we still had an hour prior to catching
    our subsequent plane house.

    Marketing is often an afterthought. When sales are down and seats are vacant, then marketing gets to be essential.
    But the reality is that advertising ought to be a component of
    the DNA of your cafe, simply because marketing is so much more than advertising.
    Advertising is something that comes in contact with your customer and leaves a lasting impact about your
    restaurant.

    There are many issues we could review and talk about regarding
    Seo. This is merely a short synopsis to ideally assist you
    turn out to be more educated and therefore much more powerful as you discover the Web and it's impact on your business.

    ReplyDelete
  3. How do you maintain your child "stranger proof"
    this summer time? When children are out of school,
    there is more time for households to make life-long lasting recollections when going out to enjoy
    fairs, festivals, and amusement parks. Here's a plan to maintain them safe.


    Suntan Lotion - it is truly easy to get burned without recognizing it in Orlando.
    Throw in a tube of suntan lotion and you'll save having to pay premium costs at the parks.


    The welcome desk was well labeled and notable on the still left hand side
    of the entry way. It was staffed with friendly helpful
    people; and there had been no lack of easy to method greeters with obviously noticeable nametags standing around expectantly hoping someone
    would inquire them a question.

    I believe there are two topics you ought to be conscious of.

    The initial is spend per click on advertising (PPC).
    PPC is the Web marketing procedure that allows you to buy access to particular keywords (we will speak in length about keywords subsequent month) and spend when somebody clicks on your ad.

    In Google these advertisements are known as Sponsored Hyperlinks.
    In Yahoo they are known as Sponsor Results. These ads
    are merely a way to buy your way to the top page of a search
    motor.

    In an attractional church, the main action of the physique, the front door exactly where people are introduced
    to the church, is focused on being comfy and exciting.

    It therefore, unintentionally, feeds the customer
    mindset already current in our society.

    Meet and Greet Shoe Pile: This works great in big teams and is a variation of the title tag ice breaker.

    Have everybody consider off 1 of their shoes and throw it into a pile.
    Have every group member pick up a shoe and stroll about the meeting space greeting other individuals as they
    attempt to match their selected shoe to the one
    an additional group member is wearing. This is a fantastic way
    for new people to satisfy a number of members in a team.



    Capture somebody's microsoft publisher name tag templates and you've received some thing firm to stand on while you pay attention to what they
    have to say. You have something firm to grab when you want to capture
    their interest. And if by opportunity they actually intrigue you and you really want to follow up with them, you are
    equipped if and only if you know their title.

    ReplyDelete